Elephants With Jobs or Elephant Tourism: The Great Debate

Say It Isn’t So : Elephants Giving Massages in Thailand : The Cruelty Behind the Gimmick and No, This is NOT ‘One For The Bucket List’

They call it phajaan or elephant crushing. It must be done, the humans say. The goal is to break the spirit of the elephant. After all there can only be one boss and it certainly isn’t the elephant. Their wishes or natural inclinations are insignificant.

So they take our elephants and put them in a cage or kraal constructed out of logs or other materials. A single elephant in a single kraal. Younger elephants, of course, can be dominated and beaten into submission more easily.

These baby elephants, and any elephant going through phajann, are tied up, (depriving them of food, sleep and water is not unheard of) kicked, prodded, beaten with sticks or the ankus (aka ankush, elephant hook, bullhook, elephant goaduntil they come to realize that they are no longer elephants.

They can no longer be elephants because humans have forfeited that life for them. They have now been assigned a job.

 One elephant at work massaging human with trunk & foot

One elephant at work massaging human with trunk & foot

In this case the job, they say, is giving a human a massage. So the young elephants, reports Ameena Schelling for The Dodo, stand diligently next to their mahout (always with a ready bullhook in their hand) and perform their newly learned tricks or tasks.

The human, explains Caroline McGuire for The Daily Mail, is on their stomach on the ground (or they have been seen on the beach stretched out on a lounge chair) lying on a mat or towel. The elephant is expected to “pummel” the human’s back with their trunks or lightly “pat them down with their feet”.

A strong, painful “yank on the ear” (elephants have extremely sensitive areas around their ears) reminds the elephant that as a masseuse she must continue to nudge her trunk in the “correct direction” or continually face the same set of circumstances.The bullhook is always in the elephant’s sight and they know, oh, they know, what that is all about.

Mahout, bullhook in hand, stands by as his elephant gives a massage in Thailand

Mahout, bullhook in hand, stands by as his elephant gives a massage in Thailand

(No mention of the cost of this service by elephants. The only costs any compassionate human could envision here are the costs of lives of these elephants, the price of their suffering. )

It is presented as a novelty in Thailand to tourists or a feat to accomplish in a lifetime and while it may initially attract one’s attention that is where the attraction has got to end.

Thai mahout stands ready with his bullhook next to his elephant giving massage

Thai mahout stands ready with his bullhook next to his elephant giving massage

Humans must be educated on the cruelty behind the novelty. The suffering our elephants have to endure for this. Elephants were not born to be anything but elephants. So, no, for the sake of our elephants, this is not “one for the bucket list.”

 

Photos credit : Creative Commons Flickr Featured elephant   one elephant massaging human  mahout with bullhook elephant   Thai mahout with bullhook elephant

 

YouTube Video Creative Commons: Elephant Massage Thailand on beach

National Geographic Training Crush Video   Note: if video fails to load click on “training crush”

See also: “We Have to Release Them. We Have to Release Them. We Have to Release Them.” Liz Jones and the Elephants

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s